Esports gives rise to multiple layers of copyright. At the foundation is the copyright in the game itself. Game developers generally hold the copyright in the finished game. They own the game copyright either by acquiring the copyrights in the original work, story, characters, artwork, video, sound and so on, or by developing these elements in-house.
When an esports company holds a gaming tournament, it naturally broadcasts it. Unlike other sporting events, esports requires spectators to watch the competition on video. The same is true even when spectators go to the esports arena in person. Watching the players themselves means little; the essence of esports is watching the play unfold on a giant screen or similar display. Here, the specific gameplay footage of an esports match becomes a derivative work that uses the game as a copyrighted work. It must necessarily be based on the original work, the game. Under this structure, the principle is that the organizer of the esports tournament pays royalties to the game developer.
In the early days of esports, however, there was little concept of copyright. Copyright issues did not even come up. From the game developers’ point of view, tournaments featuring their games, and broadcasts of those tournaments, were good for promoting their games. Even when copyright was legally infringed, it was often tacitly overlooked for the sake of game marketing. As a result, esports tournaments in various countries were sometimes held without paying royalties. Even when royalties did change hands, the amounts were small.
But the games that became esports titles grew in global popularity. The marketing effect of esports tournaments was no longer so necessary. The esports industry also grew in scale. Companies and organizations running esports leagues began generating revenue from broadcast rights, corporate sponsorships, advertising and more. Along the way, game companies came to see selling copyright licenses to various esports leagues as one of their revenue models.
Companies and organizations that had been holding esports tournaments without paying royalties, or by paying only small ones, ran into a new problem. As a result, a range of international lawsuits over esports tournaments broke out. A representative case is the litigation between Blizzard Entertainment, which holds the copyright in StarCraft, and the Korea e-Sports Association (KeSPA). KeSPA grew by organizing all kinds of gaming competitions and wielded monopoly power, yet it paid little attention to sorting out copyright. Legally, however, KeSPA could not hold and broadcast StarCraft leagues without Blizzard’s permission.
Blizzard demanded from KeSPA a sizable royalty, along with a share of corporate sponsorship revenue and sublicensing fees for VOD and other uses, but its demands were not accepted. In the end, negotiations broke down and the dispute went through the painful process of litigation. The fallout from this case became a major obstacle to the development of esports in Korea.
Unlike other sports, esports cannot exist without broadcasting. This gives it the unique characteristic that the primary copyright belongs to the game developer rather than to the tournament organizer. Without the stable foundation that comes from resolving copyright issues, esports cannot develop. New approaches and practices are needed.