The Limits of Algorithmic AdviceAI의 조언은 어디까지 믿을 수 있는가

When AI Advises on Investments, Taxes, and the LawAI가 투자·세금·법률까지 조언하는 시대의 책임과 한계

By CLG AI & Technology TeamOctober 20264 min read

Artificial intelligence is changing how individuals make financial and legal decisions. Investors can now obtain portfolio recommendations within seconds, taxpayers can ask AI systems to explain complex deductions, and families can generate preliminary estate planning documents without consulting an attorney. These services offer greater accessibility and lower costs, but they also raise an important question: when automated advice is inaccurate, who bears responsibility for the consequences?

The distinction between providing information and exercising professional judgment is becoming increasingly important. AI may analyze extensive amounts of data, but it does not necessarily understand a client's complete financial circumstances, legal obligations, or long-term objectives. In matters involving substantial assets, that distinction can have significant consequences.

AI Investment Advice and Fiduciary Responsibility

Automated investment platforms have operated in the United States for years, but generative AI has made financial recommendations more accessible to ordinary investors. Users can request stock selections, portfolio allocations, and market forecasts through conversational interfaces that resemble professional advice.

The Securities and Exchange Commission has cautioned investors against relying exclusively on AI-generated investment information, which may be inaccurate, outdated, or misleading. More importantly, the legal obligations of the service provider depend on the nature of the service being offered. An SEC-registered investment adviser remains subject to applicable fiduciary duties, including duties of care and loyalty, even when recommendations are generated through algorithms.

However, an investor consulting a general-purpose AI chatbot does not necessarily receive the protections associated with a regulated investment advisory relationship. The legal distinction between educational information and regulated investment advice therefore deserves careful consideration. The fact that an AI system produces sophisticated financial analysis does not establish that its recommendations are suitable for a particular investor.

The Risks of Automated Tax Planning

Tax planning presents additional challenges because legal outcomes frequently depend on facts that automated systems may not adequately identify.

Consider a Korean parent transferring investment assets to a child residing in the United States. An AI system may correctly identify American gift reporting requirements but overlook Korean gift tax obligations, the recipient's U.S. tax residency, or the consequences of transferring appreciated securities rather than cash. Each factor can materially affect the appropriate structure.

In 2026, the IRS Office of Professional Responsibility issued guidance addressing the use of generative AI in federal tax practice. The guidance emphasizes that practitioners must independently verify AI-generated information and consider relevant facts and legal authorities when providing tax advice. Under Circular 230, reliance on unsupported assumptions or unverified AI output may be inconsistent with professional responsibilities.

AI can assist with research and preliminary calculations. It cannot, however, eliminate the need to establish accurate facts, identify applicable jurisdictions, and verify the law governing a transaction.

Can AI Replace Legal Judgment?

Similar questions arise when AI is used to prepare contracts, trusts, or estate planning documents. Generative systems can produce documents that appear professionally drafted, often using familiar legal terminology and conventional contractual provisions. Their apparent completeness, however, does not establish that they satisfy the requirements of the applicable jurisdiction.

A trust prepared under New York law, for example, may have significant implications for a beneficiary living abroad. An estate plan involving Korean assets and American beneficiaries may require coordination between different legal systems. A document may be grammatically correct and legally recognizable while remaining unsuitable for the family's actual circumstances.

The American Bar Association addressed these concerns in Formal Opinion 512, issued in July 2024. The opinion confirms that attorneys using generative AI must continue to satisfy professional obligations involving competence, confidentiality, supervision, and communication. Attorneys must understand the limitations of the technologies they use and independently evaluate their outputs.

The underlying principle is straightforward: using technology to prepare legal work does not transfer a lawyer's professional responsibilities to the technology.

Technology, Accountability, and Professional Advice

The growing sophistication of AI should not obscure its substantial benefits. Automated tools can reduce research time, improve access to information, and help individuals identify questions they might otherwise overlook. For professionals, AI can support more efficient analysis and document preparation.

Nevertheless, professional advice involves responsibilities that extend beyond generating an answer. Investment advisers must address applicable standards of conduct and potential conflicts of interest. Tax professionals must establish reliable factual and legal foundations for their advice. Attorneys must exercise independent judgment and protect their clients' interests.

These obligations are particularly important in international matters, where a seemingly straightforward financial decision may produce consequences under several legal systems.

The appropriate role of AI is therefore not necessarily to replace professional advice, but to improve the efficiency and accessibility of the process through which informed decisions are made.

AI may increasingly determine what information is available to a client. The legal responsibility for how that information is interpreted, applied, and acted upon remains a separate question.

References
  • SEC Investor Alert — Artificial Intelligence and Investment Fraud
  • SEC — Standards of Conduct for Investment Advisers
  • American Bar Association — Formal Opinion 512
  • IRS — Responsible AI Use in Federal Tax Practice, 2026

This publication is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, tax, or investment advice. Applicable requirements depend on individual circumstances and the nature of the services involved.

← PreviousWhen Alliances Become InvestmentsNext →Cross-Border Succession Planning
CLG | Chang Law Group P.C.New York · Private Client Advisory

Planning your next step in the United States?미국에서의 다음 단계를 계획하고 계신가요?

Tell us what you would like to know about U.S. asset transfer, real estate investment, business formation, E-2 visas, and more.미국 자산 이전, 부동산 투자, 사업 설립 및 E-2 비자 등 궁금하신 내용을 남겨주세요.

Email us이메일로 문의하기

Our team will review your inquiry and get back to you.담당팀이 문의 내용을 검토한 후 연락드립니다.

Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. Your information is used only to respond to your inquiry. See our Privacy Policy.문의만으로 변호사-의뢰인 관계가 성립되지 않습니다. 입력하신 개인정보는 문의 답변 목적으로만 사용됩니다. 개인정보처리방침